How do you like them apples?

Pollan, M. 2001. The Botany of Desire: A Plant’s-Eye View of the World. Randon House Trade Paperbacks, New York, New York. P3-58, 183-238.

This week’s reading was “Chapter 1 Desire: Sweetness/ Plant: The Apple” and “Chapter 4 Desire: Control/ Plant: The Potato” from Pollan’s, “The Botany of Desire.” As mentioned on a previous blog post, Pollan’s “The Botany of Desire” discusses four desires that plants prey on humans for. The desires covered this week were sweetness and control.

As usual, Pollan is able to give character to the plants in question. He provides in both chapters a history of the apple and potato and how they have influenced humans over the years. Again, we see the apple and potato showing up in important colonization events, federal policy making and modern day advances. He reminds us that the relationship between plants and people is mutual. On page 5 he says, “We give ourselves altogether too much credit in our dealings with other species… It takes two to perform that particular dance, after all, and plenty of plants and animals have elected to sit out.” What Pollan means here is that all plants that have been domesticated by humans were chosen by humans but the plants also had to “choose” to be domesticated by people.

What I found interesting about Chapter 1, was how much religion and government were involved in altering the history of the apple. Pollan states that as John Chapman’s (a.k.a. Johnny Appleseed) apple orchards spread across America, religious groups got involved because in that day and time, apples were used primarily for making cider. On page 22 Pollan mentions the popular slogan, “an apple a day keeps the doctor away” (a saying I’ll admit I think to myself every time I eat an apple) is the product of a marketing strategy to change the reputation of apples as an alcoholic beverage to apples as a nutritious food. I also find it funny how the image of Johnny Appleseed has changed so much. Bill describes Chapman’s best characteristics on as, “his philanthropy, his selflessness, his Christian faith… was also America’s first environmentalist” (p.24). However, the image Pollan describes of Chapman is of a crazy man with a child bride. Certainly not the role model Bill had described.

I enjoyed reading Chapter 4 much more than Chapter 1. This was the chapter on control. I liked this chapter because Pollan raised a lot of questions on the ethics of genetically modified (GM) crops. Pollan has argued in all of his books that the relationship between plants and people is mutual and that the plants are as much in control as humans are. However, in the case of GM seeds, it appears Pollan may be wrong. It is true that through artificial selection humans have been modifying the characteristics of crops throughout history but have humans taken it too far? “Now the once irreducible wilderness of these plants has been… reduced” (p.196). By directly altering the genome of these plants we are taking away their potential to evolve. It seems to me that these scientists feel as if they can do a better job than nature so they have removed Her from the picture.

Although it now seems like humans have finally found a way to take complete control over plants, I would argue that this isn’t the case. Human’s will never be able to completely control nature. For example, GM crops that produce insecticide will eventually produce insecticide resistant bugs which will render these GM crops worthless. Monsanto claims that once this occurs a new and improved pesticide will solve the problem but how many times will this have to happen until the new pesticide doesn’t work? The lack of research on GM crops and mis-placed trust we put into Monsanto is very concerning for me. The human desire to control nature might just be our greatest weakness as humans. As the famous Dr. Ian Malcolm would say, “life finds a way.”

Advertisements
How do you like them apples?

3 thoughts on “How do you like them apples?

  1. Samantha Suppanz says:

    I really like your post titles. It was interesting to see how they evolved from just the title of the books to the witty headings you have now. I agree with your interest of the involvement of religion and government with apples. It’s fascinating just thinking about how something so popular and accepted today (an apple a day keeps the doctor away) was something that arose due to concerned mothers in the past. It makes me wonder what the university students of the future will think about our present day society. Also, you though you could sneak in a Jurassic Park reference without anyone noticing didn’t you? Well I did… and kudos for that. I think that those words sum up genetic engineering perfectly.

    Like

  2. Great blog!

    I read this post because the title makes me laugh. I enjoyed reading this post for a few reasons. First, I like how you stated the desires that Pollan covers in these chapters. It introduces me to Pollan’s book, as well as to what you’ll be talking about in your blog post.

    Second, I like your post because I agree with a lot of things you say. I too was surprised about how much religion and politics were involved in the history of the apple and the potato. Who knew that food was so complicated and political?

    I also preferred reading chapter 4 to chapter 1. I have so many questions and concerns about GM crops so it was interesting to see Pollan’s investigation into their background. I agree that us as humans will never be able to take complete control over nature and that there is a huge lack of information on GM crops. This concerns me because there is a misplaced trust in Monsanto’s “research”, as well as obliviousness from the general public.

    I really like how you ended your blog post. I agree that our desire to control the world is a huge weakness of the human population. It has gotten us into so many world altering disasters

    Overall, you have a great blog and this post was enjoyable to read. Your title drew me in and your own thoughts and questions kept me interested.

    Good job ☺

    Like

  3. anishaparekh says:

    Your titles are fantastic! It is a great idea to have titles like this because it really makes me go, “whah! what is this about!?” It drew me in instantly. You have a great end to your post as well. Its great ending on a quote. A strong beginning and ending really puts an OOMPHHH to your posts. Your posts are very funny and light to read.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s